Thursday, November 19. As part of its ongoing educational outreach, the Jewish community of Porto organized a “conversation with students” for the first time. Sixty students from schools in Paços de Ferreira attended and expressed great enthusiasm for the opportunity to learn from the Jewish community.
The discussion took place in the Rosh Pinah Library, surrounded by a rich collection of literature and paintings that depict the centuries-long history of the Jewish community in the “Invincible City” of Porto. The choice of venue was no accident, as the 10,000 books demonstrate the Jewish commitment to culture; the thirteen languages represented in these volumes reflect the international diversity of the Jewish people; and the gallery of paintings—created in just three months—vividly illustrates the “thought and action” dynamic of the international Jewish community.
In a country where cultural projects typically take years to conceive and just as long to execute, the Porto community has often shown an ability to produce significant cultural works in remarkably short timeframes—sometimes in a matter of days or weeks.
David Garrett, a member of the Board, led the conversation with the students, accompanied by Erez Vaguima, the shamash of the Kadoorie Synagogue. The last explained the responsibilities involved in managing the temple, while the main questions of the students were addressed by the board member.
Among the many inquiries from the students, one question—posed three times from different perspectives—concerned why the Jewish people have received such a large number of Nobel Prizes. Garrett explained that there are two possible answers to this question. “The first explanation is the conspiratorial one: that Jews control everything—even the juries for the Nobel Prizes. The second explanation, which we consider to be the correct one, is simpler: from childhood, a Jew is raised to live in such a way that their earthly existence is not wasted. By the end of their life, they should be able to say: ‘My life was worth living, for I managed to contribute to the Creation.’
A young woman with an intellectual face then asked why it is that the first word people associate with Jews is ‘money.’ David Garrett welcomed the question, calling it highly analytical and intelligent. "Centuries ago," he explained, "when some Jews prospered in the few professions open to them—primarily commerce—the social elites who were hostile toward them began to associate the entire Jewish community with the wealth of a mere few. Thus was born the 'money' label that has been pinned on the Jewish community as a whole ever since, in every country."
The teacher of the young students asked how the Jewish community manages to handle money in a productive way. The answer was resounding: "Like the wind, money can be helpful—provided you are well-educated and know the right path. If you are well-educated, your life will be a waste, an idiot as full of material goods as he is of psychological problems and suicidal tendencies. If you do not know the right path, you will be paralyzed, your life will become chaotic, and there will be no shortage of thieves waiting to rob you."
The discussion extended to the subject of Jewish success and the inability of those who oppose Jews to come to terms with it. The community leader explained that "The most striking example of this antagonism toward Jewish success concerns the State of Israel, which, in less than eighty years, has become a scientific and nuclear power—yet it is never associated with this achievement, but rather only with negative factors. If this happens with a state, it is obvious that it also happens with prosperous Jewish communities and even with individual Jews.”
"Conversation with students" is a new educational model that the Jewish community of Porto inaugurated this Thursday. Learning about Jewish philosophy can be highly beneficial for Portuguese school students, helping them understand how Jewish communities have shaped societies.
After a very productive hour, the conversation came to an end. The students headed toward the Jewish museum, from where they also set off to visit the Holocaust museum.