Jewish museum remembers how the Alter Rebbe was unfairly accused of "Treasonous Funding"

Jewish museum remembers how the Alter Rebbe was unfairly accused of

On 19 Kislev 5559 (November 27, 1798), Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi—known as the Alter Rebbe and the founder of Chabad Hasidism—was freed after spending 53 days imprisoned in St. Petersburg's infamous Peter and Paul Fortress.

Grandson of Rabbi Baruch Portugal, the Alter Rebbe paid a high price for his dedication to promoting Jewish life. Tensions ran high between the emerging Hasidic movement and the Mitnagdim (traditionalist opponents), particularly after the Alter Rebbe published his seminal work, the Tanya, in 1796.

Opponents of Hasidism lodged a denunciation with the Tsarist authorities in Russia, falsely accusing Rabbi Schneur Zalman of subversion against the crown. Key among the accusations was that his financial support (Colel Chabad) for Jewish communities in the Holy Land—then under the rule of the Ottoman Empire, an enemy of Russia—was actually treasonous funding sent to the Sultan.

Rabbi Schneur Zalman of Liadi was arrested in the fall of 1798 and brought to St. Petersburg. During his 53 days in confinement, he was interrogated by high-ranking imperial ministers who questioned both his political loyalty and the core tenets of Hasidic philosophy.

In a famous recorded interaction during his interrogation, a knowledgeable minister asked him to explain the verse from Genesis 3:9 ("Where are you?"), asking how an omniscient God could seemingly not know Adam's whereabouts. The Alter Rebbe explained that the question is timeless—God continuously asks every human being at every stage of life, "Where are you in your world? What have you done with the days and years you were given?"

Tsar Paul I reviewed the case, found no evidence of treason or wrongdoing, and ordered his unconditional release on the 19th of Kislev.

His acquittal was viewed as divine sanction to openly disseminate Chabad teachings. In Hasidic tradition, the earthly trial mirrored a prosecution in the heavenly court over whether the inner, mystical dimensions of Torah (Chassidus) should be widely revealed to the public.

Approximately 228 years have passed since the episode described. The Alter Rebbe's efforts have more than paid off. Today, Chabad is widely recognized as the most global and fast-growing Jewish outreach movements, with permanent emissary couples and centers operating in over 120 countries.

The 43rd International Conference of Chabad-Lubavitch Emissaries (Kinus Hashluchim) took place in New York (Brooklyn) from November 4 through November 9, 2026, bringing together 6,500 rabbis and emissaries (shluchim) from more than 100 countries and every U.S. state.

The annual gathering unites leaders of the global Chabad network to attend workshops, share Torah study, connect with colleagues, pray at the Ohel (resting place of Rabbi Menachem M. Schneerson, the Rebbe) in Queens, and set goals and direction for Jewish communities worldwide.