The Belmonte Family: Wealth, persecution and tragedy in Nazi-Era Hamburg

The Belmonte Family: Wealth, persecution and tragedy in Nazi-Era Hamburg

Gustav Abendana Belmonte, born August 13, 1891, in Hamburg; imprisoned at the Fuhlsbüttel concentration camp in 1938/1939; deported to Theresienstadt on July 19, 1942; deported to Auschwitz on October 16, 1944.

Jenny Belmonte, née Simon, born December 21, 1860, in Altona; deported to Theresienstadt on July 19, 1942; died there on May 13, 1944.

Alfred Belmonte, born September 4, 1895, in Hamburg; murdered on April 29, 1939, at the Fuhlsbüttel concentration camp.

Paul Belmonte, born June 2, 1894, in Hamburg; murdered on April 29, 1939, at the Fuhlsbüttel concentration camp.

Salomon Belmonte, born September 29, 1890, in Hamburg; murdered on April 30, 1939, at the Fuhlsbüttel concentration camp.

Wilibald Belmonte, born September 27, 1892, in Hamburg; deported to Minsk on November 8, 1941.

Eppendorfer Weg 62

The Portuguese-Jewish Belmonte family—whose ancestors may have resided in Hamburg as early as the 17th century—is representative of long-established, affluent Hamburg Jews whose process of assimilation went hand in hand with social advancement. Salomon Abendana Belmonte (born in 1843), who held a doctorate in law, worked as an attorney, merchant, and journalist; he also served as editor-in-chief of the periodical Die Reform, was a member of the "Ferdinande Caroline" Masonic lodge, and sat in the Hamburg Parliament (Hamburgische Bürgerschaft) until his death in 1888. Furthermore, he served as a board member of the Portuguese-Jewish Community in Hamburg. His brother, Michael Abendana Belmonte (born in 1855, died in 1939), enjoyed a successful career in finance and founded a bank, which he operated—later in partnership with his son Willibald—until 1938 at a prime Hamburg location: Jungfernstieg 30. Michael Belmonte also served on the board of the Portuguese-Jewish Community, whose synagogues were located on Markusstraße and, later, at Innocentiastraße 37. The parents of Salomon Abendana Belmonte and Michael Belmonte were Salomon Abendana Belmonte and Brayne Belmonte, née Wagner.

Michael Belmonte and Jenny Simon were married on June 20, 1889. The couple had five sons: Salomon Abendana (born in 1890), Gustav Abendana (born in 1891), Wilibald Abendana (born in 1892), Paul Philipp Abendana (born in 1894), and Alfred Isaac Abendana (born in 1895), all of whom later pursued careers as merchants. At the time of their sons' births, the family lived at Marienstraße 59 in St. Pauli—a street now known as Simon-von-Utrecht-Straße. By the turn of the century, the family had moved to Schanzenstraße 62. The parents’ marriage ended in divorce in 1905.

Until the 1930s, the brothers and their father, Michael Abendana Belmonte, owned various businesses; however, based on the information provided in city directories, it is not always possible to distinguish between their private residences and their business addresses.

In 1934/35, the brothers Alfred and Paul Belmonte moved from Schanzenstraße 62 to Schäferkampsallee 11, which served as both their private residence and the address of their firm, P(aul) and A(lfred) Belmonte. Their father, Michael Belmonte, also lived with them at Schäferkampsallee 11. His bank was located at Jungfernstieg 30, which also housed a commission agency operated by Paul and Alfred Belmonte. In 1938, both businesses were relocated to Neuer Wall 54/60. At their residence on Schäferkampsallee, the father and sons employed a Jewish housekeeper, Bertha Simon (born November 12, 1862). She was deported to Theresienstadt on March 10, 1943, where she passed away later that same year at the age of 81.

In the precarious situation of 1938, what could the Belmontes—five adult sons in their prime, all men of considerable means active in the banking and business sectors—have done to avert their ruin? As bankers, they would surely have been able to gauge the consequences of the restrictive measures imposed by the foreign exchange offices, which sought to strip Jews wishing to emigrate of their assets—or at least of their ability to freely dispose of them—through various taxes, levies, and "sequestration orders." In a November 1938 audit report on the family, the Regional Finance Office (Oberfinanzdirektion) noted: "No intentions to emigrate have been established." There is no evidence whatsoever to suggest that the Belmontes attempted to circumvent foreign exchange laws—for instance, by illegally transferring funds abroad. Nevertheless, the foreign exchange authorities kept a particularly close watch on bankers and other individuals suspected of "capital flight."

In September 1938, a "sequestration order" was issued against Michael Belmonte, covering the contents of his bank safe-deposit boxes; from that point on, he could only access them with the explicit authorization of the Hamburg foreign exchange office. Prior to this, customs investigators had searched the safe-deposit boxes held by the Belmontes at various banks and transferred the securities found therein into restricted accounts at the Vereinsbank and the Deutsche Bank. This is documented in a letter from October 1938, in which the customs investigation unit informed the foreign exchange office of a suspected case of "capital flight" involving Michael and Wilibald Belmonte. Furthermore, the customs investigators recommended that a formal audit of their foreign exchange dealings be initiated. The intention was to seize Willibald Belmonte’s private assets—a move that proved impossible at the time, as no distinction could yet be made between his business assets and his personal wealth. In December 1938, a "sequestration order" (Sicherungsanordnung) was issued against Willibald Belmonte, based on allegations of foreign exchange violations. However, inquiries made to his banks revealed no evidence of any "irregularities." His shares held at the Vereinsbank were already frozen by the Hamburg-Neustadt tax office, and he held no private securities account at the Deutsche Bank.

The November Pogrom had grave consequences for the Belmonte family. The closure of the firm Michael Belmonte was imminent; according to an official memorandum, it entered into liquidation on December 31, 1938. Alfred and Salomon Belmonte were among the 900 men—mostly from affluent Jewish families—who were taken to the Fuhlsbüttel concentration camp in the wake of the pogrom and subsequently deported to the Sachsenhausen concentration camp. They were released in January 1939, presumably because the family had made preparations for their emigration. Ultimately, however, they did not emigrate. In April 1939, the customs investigation office initiated proceedings against the owners of the Michael Belmonte banking firm, among others, based on "urgent suspicion of violating the Foreign Exchange Act." Willibald and Gustav Belmonte were arrested and interrogated. The files do not provide specific details regarding the nature of the alleged violation; it can be assumed that the family had attempted—an act classified as a criminal offense—to transfer their own funds or assets abroad. In July, an article appeared in the Hamburg press that provided further details. It stated that the brothers Gustav and Wilibald Belmonte had violated an order to surrender their holdings of precious metals to a public state-run purchasing agency. They were accused of failing to hand over “a gold watch with a chain, cufflinks, and cutlery,” and of attempting instead to transfer these items to the Netherlands via intermediaries. The brothers were sentenced to six and ten weeks in prison, respectively, and each was fined 200 Reichsmarks.

The pretexts used for the persecution and humiliation related not only to the business conduct of the male family members but also to their private lives. A transcript of an interrogation from April 1939 has survived in the files. Wilibald was subjected to a humiliating questioning session in which he was accused of "racial defilement" (Rassenschande) with a prostitute and forced to provide detailed information about his sexual practices.

The arrest of the family by the Gestapo at the end of April 1939 must be viewed in the context of these ongoing investigations: on April 26, 27, and 28, all the Belmonte brothers, along with their mother, Jenny Belmonte, were arrested by the Gestapo and taken to the Fuhlsbüttel concentration camp. According to the recollections of Max Plaut, the managing director of the Jewish Religious Association, only three of the brothers were arrested; a fourth reportedly managed to escape. Max Plaut was attending a meeting when he received a phone call—presumably from the Gestapo—informing him: "The three Belmonte brothers are dead. They hanged themselves." (...) In fact, all three had been hanged from the crossbar of a window. Under the supervision of the Gestapo, the bodies of the brothers—Alfred, Paul, and Salomon Belmonte—were washed by members of the Jewish community. "The bodies were terribly battered from beatings. They must have been struck with tools; all three had been beaten beyond recognition." The Gestapo issued the death certificates, listing "suicide by hanging" as the cause of death for each of them. Although the brothers were presumably tortured to death on the same day, the Gestapo recorded different dates of death: according to these records, Alfred and Paul Belmonte died on April 29, 1939, at Suhrenkamp 98, while their brother Salomon died a day later. Today, the site at Suhrenkamp 98 houses the Fuhlsbüttel Concentration Camp and Penal Institutions Memorial. Michael Belmonte survived the murder of his sons by only a few days. He died on May 1, 1939, at the age of 83, in the Jewish Hospital—possibly as a result of a suicide attempt. The death register lists sclerosis and pneumonia as the causes of death. In September 1940, the Reich Supervisory Office for the Credit System accelerated the liquidation of his firm by appointing a liquidator, the auditor Heinrich Mäurer. The proceedings also affected Jenny Belmonte and her sons Gustav and Wilibald—the latter being a co-owner of the firm. A letter from the liquidator indicates that the firm held a large portfolio of securities and that business and private assets had not yet been separated. Consequently, the auditor proposed extending a "seizure order" to all securities belonging to the firm of Michael Belmonte. Five months later, at the end of February 1941, the separation of assets was complete, allowing the auditor to announce the conclusion of the liquidation of the firm of Michael Belmonte. In the meantime, a "seizure order" had also been issued against Gustav Belmonte.

The 1942 address book still listed Jenny and Wilibald Belmonte at Eppendorfer Weg 62, even though this entry was long outdated. Wilibald Belmonte had already been deported to Minsk on November 8, 1941. In July 1942, a violin and a typewriter belonging to him were sold at a public auction. Beginning in May 1942, Gustav Belmonte lived at Rutschbahn 25a, Building 1—presumably together with his mother, who was registered at that address in 1942. The building was a so-called "Judenhaus" (a house designated for Jews). On July 19, 1942, Jenny and Gustav Belmonte were deported to Theresienstadt.

The tragic story of the Belmonte family illustrates not only that long-established, respected, and affluent Jewish families were prevented from emigrating by the Nazi regime’s policy of expropriation, but also that they were, in fact, subjected to particularly relentless persecution.

The files provide further details regarding the life of Gustav Abendana Belmonte: born in St. Pauli, he attended the Realschule (secondary school) there, where he obtained the qualification for one-year voluntary military service (Einjähriges). Afterward, he undertook a commercial apprenticeship at a Hamburg firm and, for several years leading up to the outbreak of the war in 1914, worked as a clerk for the company Orenstein & Koppel in Berlin. He subsequently joined the firm Schaefer & Scael in Düsseldorf before becoming a soldier in 1915. He took part in the Russian campaign and returned to Germany at the end of 1915, where he found work as a temporary postal assistant with the Reichspost (Imperial Postal Service) in Düsseldorf. Following this, he worked at the Düsseldorf-based safe manufacturer Peltz, where he remained until 1920. Later, he returned to his father in Hamburg and worked temporarily in his father’s banking business. However, Gustav Abendana had artistic interests and was likely never truly satisfied with his commercial pursuits. He contemplated studying music and underwent training as an actor and singer. In 1929—at the age of 38—he took on various commercial agency roles, during which time he continued to receive financial support from his father, with whom he was also living toward the end. At the time of his arrest and interrogation, he identified his profession as a sales representative for oils and fats. A passport application record from 1924, when Gustav Abendana Belmonte applied for a passport for travel to Denmark and Sweden, provides details about his physical appearance: he was of medium height, with an elongated face, dark brown eyes, and black hair.

Gustav Abendana Belmonte survived the horrific conditions of imprisonment in Theresienstadt, including hunger and other hardships. Yet, he could not escape being transported onward to Auschwitz in October 1944. This transport on October 16, 1944, which included approximately 1,500 people, is also referred to as the "artists' transport." Up until that point, the National Socialists had used the artists in Theresienstadt for propaganda purposes, presenting the camp as a "model Jewish settlement." Many musicians and composers who had participated in the opera Brundibár were sent to their deaths on this transport.