“The Human-Looking Animals” – By David Garrett

“The Human-Looking Animals” – By David Garrett

A classic Jewish parable illustrates the historical dialogue between science and Kabbalah, suggesting that both seek to answer the same questions, albeit following different paths. The most celebrated version of the metaphor was popularized by the American astronomer Robert Jastrow in his book God and the Astronomers (1978), where he describes the moment when the best scientists, having just climbed and reached the summit of the Mountain of Creation, come across a group of Torah rabbis who soon told them, "We told you so."

In agnostic societies, Judaism is often mocked for marking the beginning of the calendar 5787 years ago. Two facts of the utmost importance are ignored. The first is that the beginning of the Jewish calendar marks the emergence of the first human being endowed with a rational soul and spiritual consciousness (Neshama), this was the beginning of civilization. The second is that modern science recognizes that the beginning of civilization (Mesopotamia and Writing) is actually dated to a time span between 5500 and 6000 years ago. The temporal coincidence is real, bothworld views deport us to the same transitional historical horizon of the Ancient Bronze Age.

In his philosophical masterpiece ‘Guide to the Perplexed’, Maimonides explains that before they developed their intellect fully and possessed Neshamah, individuals were not “men” in the full sense, but rather "resembled animals with human appearance." There had been hundreds of generations of hominids before. Jewish tradition recognizes this, as does modern science. Numerous objective scientific elements attest that the history of the Homo Sapiens species arose about 300,000 years ago.

For modern science, the man from whom all living humans descend (called "Y-Chromosome Adam") lived about 200,000 years ago, while the woman from whom all living humans descend ("Mitochondrial Eve") lived about 150,000 years ago. Both lived with other hominids in their time, but they were the only ones whose direct lineages have survived uninterrupted to this day.

In Kabbalistic and mystical interpretations of Bereshit, the names Adam and Eve are given to the first beings to receive a complete human soul (Neshamah). To reconcile Jewish tradition (which places biblical Adam and Eve about 5787 years ago) with modern genetics (Y-Chromosomal Adam and Mitochondrial Eve, who lived hundreds of thousands of years ago) is not an arduous task. All four are direct ancestors of humanity, but while the biblical Adam and Eve are theological figures who represent the framework of humanity's moral and spiritual responsibility, the Mitochondrial Adam-Y and Eve are the "human-looking animals" to which Maimonides referred.

In the modern world, in November 2026, how does the common man stand in the middle of this debate between Kabbalah and science? Judaism claims that it is the obligation of each one to be a marker of moral and spiritual responsibility, far removed from "animals with human appearance". Modern science does not give any advice to human beings. The Jewish perspective of life therefore becomes the only one that teaches and advises.

Kabbalah teaches that God created the world deliberately incomplete so that humanity could be a partner in Creation. Each soul descends to Earth with a plan and a quota of spiritual work that no one else can accomplish. The circumstances of each person's life, their talents, vocations, temptations, the opportunities they enjoy, and the difficulties they face are the stage designed by the Universe for the soul to complete its mission. Each person's mission is unique, personal, and non-transferable. It is an individual process of purification and spiritual correction.

The moral mission of every human being is to be just, to educate, and to elevate his inner animal nature. It is up to him to transform his egocentric desire ("to receive only for himself") into an altruistic desire ("to receive with the intention of sharing, enriching the world as a whole and connecting with Creation"). Each person's life will dictate their destiny.

Those who have a failed existence, without producing anything useful in life, and even trying to torpedo the earthly mission of others, will lose themselves in terrible forms of reincarnation (Gilgul Neshamot or the rotation or transmigration of souls), associated with lower forms, such as wild animals, plants and even minerals. Instead, the soul that completes its part in the Work of Creation (Tikkun Olam) reaches the maximum spiritual elevation and frees itself from the cycle of reincarnations. It no longer needs to return to the physical world.

The soul that fulfills its mission ascends to Gan Eden Elyon (Upper Eden), where it experiences immeasurable spiritual pleasure in understanding the deep secrets of Creation. The soul's greatest pleasure comes from the fact that it has gained its light through its own choices and actions in the physical world. Because it has completed the Work of Creation on its own merit, it enjoys the divine light with full dignity and fullness.

Kabbalah teaches that in the final stage of cosmic history; perfect souls will return to a purified and spiritualized physical body. In this state, the material world itself will be completely elevated, and the soul will live eternally in perfect harmony between spirit and matter. The final destiny of this soul involves deep states of consciousness and spiritual existence.

In the Kabbalistic view, Olam Haba (the world to come) is not a geographical place, but a dimension of pure light and closeness to the Creator. When a soul fulfills its mission, it raises the divine sparks (Nitzotzot) trapped in the material world and fully completes its spiritual correction (Tikkun). The soul unites with the source of all light (Ein Sof, the Eternal), maintaining its individualized identity just enough to appreciate and reflect divine love and wisdom without the barrier of ego or suffering.

The scientific perspective, stuck in test tubes where it is not possible to insert the Rationality that surrounds the Universe, turns out to be a merely animal perspective. The debate is reduced only to mathematics, in the sense that each person living today theoretically has at least 275 generations behind him since the beginning of civilization in Mesopotamia and at least 10,000 generations of direct ancestors within the history of the species of Homo Sapiens that emerged three hundred millennia ago. The reasoning is right. But a question remains: What next?