Nazi flag to go under the hammer in Madeira

Nazi flag to go under the hammer in Madeira

A Nazi flag once owned by Emil Franz Gesche, the former German consul in Funchal during the Second World War, is set to go up for auction in Madeira. The appearance of a symbol associated with Adolf Hitler’s regime in a commercial sale has attracted attention, both because of its provenance and the historical significance it carries.

The flag is part of the collection of Quinta Olavo, also known as Quinta do Alemão (the German’s Estate), a property that served as the residence of successive German consuls in Madeira. Its history is closely linked to Gesche, whose time on the island was also marked by his relationship with members of the German Jewish community.

Described as a moderate individual, Gesche maintained friendly relations with German Jews living in Madeira. Among his closest connections was Gilbert Schnitzer, a prominent Jewish businessman with whom he entered into a business partnership.

That relationship eventually came to the attention of German agents working for the Gestapo in Madeira. Their connection was reported to Berlin, forcing Gesche and Schnitzer to dissolve their business partnership.

The inclusion of the flag in the auction adds another dimension to its history. Beyond its potential rarity and appeal to collectors, it raises the question of what place objects associated with regimes responsible for persecution and crimes against humanity should have in the marketplace. Preserving them as historical artefacts is one thing; assigning commercial value to symbols that continue to carry such a deeply troubling meaning is quite another.